It’s clear that I prefer a rifle like an AR-15 for home defense. I’ve still got my shotguns, I’ve still got my handguns, but if there’s an ability to have a preference, AR-15 is it.
I feel my main AR is fairly well set up as a “fightin'” gun for home needs, including things like having a light on the fore-rail. The one thing I feel I is missing is a good scope/sights. I do have iron sights on it and they work well enough, but I really want to get a red-dot scope such as an Aimpoint. The reason is simple: target acquisition is faster.
So what model to get? Well, I don’t need night vision. I like the optic to be rugged. I want it to be simple (thus the Aimpoint over the EOTech) I do like the battery life as the point is to be a gun always at the ready, so turn it on, leave it on, and when/if I need the gun it’s ready to go no need to have to waste time turning on the optic; just change the batteries once a year. I was originally leaning towards the ML3 because I could get it in a 2 MOA dot. The M4 or M4S would be awesome: best design, uses a common AA battery and has amazing life, but wicked expensive. Tom Givens said all the top 3-gun competition guys were using the ML2; I don’t know why, but my guess is it’s least expensive and the 4 MOA dot is good enough in terms of precision but also a bigger dot means your eye picks it up a lot faster and thus you can get to shooting sooner. That’s some food for thought. The more I pondered that, the more I felt that yes, a 4 MOA dot would be better for my particular purpose of a home-defense/fighting rifle. I doubt I’d be taking shots beyond 100 yards. This is not a sniper/accuracy rifle, and 4″ at 100 yards is still minute-of-dead-bad-guy. If I was taking a shot inside the home, 25 yards is probably my longest shot, with more common distances maybe 10 yards give or take 5 yards.
So as of this writing, my feeling is to get the ML2. Or if for some reason I want the ML3, at least getting it in the 4 MOA configuration. I should say for the longest time I wanted the 2 MOA because I’ve got this thing about precision. People say you can buy the 2 MOA version and crank the brightness up until the dot “blooms” and then it’s bigger: you can make a 2 MOA dot a 4 MOA dot, but you can’t make a 4 MOA dot 2 MOA. There’s something to that, but when I look at a bloomed dot it’s “fuzzy” and distracting. Might be fine for some, but not for me. I can’t make the gun into an “everything” gun. It has a purpose, I need to build for that purpose and have a good rifle for that purpose, instead of a tool that’s half-assed for any/every purpose.
But…
I’m reconsidering getting any sort of sight/scope/optics.
The main reason is money, but also priority.
After taking the Combined Skills class, one thing Tom Givens made clear was that home invasions (where there’s a victim in the house) aren’t as frequent as we might think. Rather I should say, in his years of research, most violent crimes — especially where a gun is used to defend the victim — tend to happen at not-home: on the street, parking lots, etc.. Why are most of the stories of “person defends themselves with a gun” home invasion stories? Because at home is where most people in the USA have access to a gun. Something like half of the households in the USA have a gun in them. How many private citizens are legally allowed to carry a handgun on the street? About 3% of the population. Thus, when you hear the stories, you have to think of it in that context.
It’s not that I don’t want to have a good home-defense gun. But rather, I already have a sighting mechanism on my AR and it’s a good sighting mechanism. I get hits just fine with irons. But perhaps my money (the $500 it will cost for the Aimpoint plus a LaRue Tactical mount) might be better spent on a couple cases of ammo and more time at the range with my handgun. So, where to prioritize? Getting more gear for one thing, or spending the time/money on continuing to hone another thing.
I don’t know. This thought only just occurred to me this morning in the aftermath of the Combined Skills class. It’s something to think about. Not like I’ve got the money right now anyway… gotta think about braces for Oldest. 😯
